Our Vacation Rental Had Amazing Reviews—And One Shocking Secret

The Perfect Getaway

I'm Emma, 32, and I've been engaged to Daniel for just over a year now. We both work crazy hours at our marketing jobs in Chicago, so when vacation time finally rolled around, we were desperate for something special.

"Let's skip the generic hotel experience this time," Daniel suggested one night while we were scrolling through travel sites.

That's when we found it—a stunning oceanfront rental with floor-to-ceiling windows and a private pool that looked straight out of a celebrity's Instagram.

The listing had hundreds of five-star reviews, with guests raving about the host's "exceptional attention to detail" and "anticipating needs before you even have them." I remember thinking it seemed almost too perfect as I scrolled through the professional photos.

The price was steep but not outrageous for what was offered. "This is the one," I told Daniel, already imagining us sipping wine on that gorgeous balcony.

We booked it immediately, counting down the days until our perfect getaway. Little did I know that those glowing reviews were hiding something that would turn our dream vacation into a nightmare I still can't shake.

Image by RM AI

Too Good to Be True

As our departure date approached, I found myself falling down a rabbit hole of reviews for Richard's oceanfront paradise.

Every night after work, I'd curl up with my laptop and scroll through page after page of glowing testimonials.

"Richard anticipated our every need!" one reviewer gushed. "It's like he was reading our minds," wrote another.

I started taking screenshots of the most effusive ones to send to Daniel. "Listen to this one," I texted him.

"'Richard somehow knew I preferred almond milk in my coffee without me mentioning it. The attention to detail is UNREAL.

'" Daniel responded with an eye-roll emoji. "Babe, you're obsessing. It's just a vacation rental." But something about the reviews nagged at me.

They were all so... perfect. Too perfect? I tried to brush off the feeling, chalking it up to pre-vacation jitters.

Still, I couldn't help noticing how many guests mentioned Richard's uncanny ability to anticipate their needs.

"It's like he was watching us," one review said, followed by a laughing emoji. I stared at those words for a long time, an inexplicable chill running down my spine.

Why did that particular phrase make me so uneasy?

Image by RM AI

Arrival

After five hours of travel, our rental car finally crunched up the gravel driveway of what would be our home for the next week.

I gasped as we rounded the bend—the photos hadn't lied. The modern glass structure seemed to float above the cliff edge, with the endless blue ocean stretching beyond.

"We're here!" Daniel squeezed my hand, his excitement matching mine. As we stepped out of the car, the front door swung open, revealing Richard—a tall, silver-haired man probably in his sixties, dressed impeccably in linen.

"Emma and Daniel! Welcome, welcome," he called, as if greeting old friends. He ushered us inside with a tray of chilled rosé and what he called "my famous lemon pastries." The interior was even more stunning—minimalist furniture, pristine white walls, and those promised floor-to-ceiling windows framing the ocean like living artwork.

"I've prepared everything just as you like it," Richard said, his smile warm but his eyes... something about his eyes seemed to be studying us, cataloging our reactions.

I brushed the thought away as he showed us to the master suite. "The sheets are Egyptian cotton, and I've left lavender sachets under the pillows—helps with jet lag." How did he know we'd be jet-lagged?

I didn't remember mentioning our connecting flight from Chicago. But before I could dwell on it, Daniel pulled me onto the balcony, and the view literally took my breath away.

What I didn't realize then was that someone else's breath was being taken away too—watching us from somewhere I couldn't see.

Image by RM AI

The Perfect Host

Richard led us through the house with the practiced ease of someone who'd given this tour hundreds of times.

"I believe the little touches make all the difference," he said, opening the bathroom door to reveal beach towels folded into perfect origami swans.

I exchanged an impressed glance with Daniel as Richard continued to the kitchen, where he swung open the fridge door with a flourish.

"Local cheeses, fresh-caught fish, and that wine is from a vineyard just twenty minutes away." The attention to detail was staggering—he'd even stocked my favorite brand of sparkling water without me mentioning it.

"I want my guests to feel completely at home," Richard explained, demonstrating the high-tech security system with its multiple cameras.

"Not that you'll need it out here, but safety first!" He mentioned casually that he lived in a small cottage just down the hill—"Close enough if you need anything, far enough for your privacy." As he finally handed over the keys, his fingers lingered against mine a moment too long, his eyes holding mine with an intensity that made me instinctively pull back.

I noticed Daniel's slight frown, his arm sliding protectively around my waist. "Well," Richard said, that perfect host smile never wavering, "I'll leave you two lovebirds to settle in." As he walked away, I couldn't shake the feeling that even though he was leaving, he wasn't really going anywhere at all.

Image by RM AI