The Strange Alchemy Of Talking To A Stranger
Therapy sits at that odd intersection of being both something incredibly basic—in essence, talking—as well as a professional practice with a rigorous body of scientific evidence behind it. Before psychologists existed, people confessed to priests, or unburdened themselves around fires, or wrote long unsent letters in candlelight. Now, they book an hour with someone who listens and takes notes as they unpack their childhood trauma. Sometimes these sessions change everything. Sometimes it feels like setting money on fire. Here are ten reasons why therapy can be helpful, and ten reasons why it may not be worth the cost.
1. You Finally Say The Unsayable
There’s power in speaking words you’ve only rehearsed silently at night in front of the mirror. Once said aloud to a stranger, the shame paradoxically dissipates, and a secret that you’ve carried in your chest like a hefty stone suddenly becomes as light as a pebble.
Priscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦 on Unsplash
2. Someone Actually Listens Without Interrupting
Most conversations are a race for air time. Therapy isn’t. A good therapist doesn’t check their phone or interject with their own stories and opinions. That silence—charged, intentional—feels rare in today’s attention-seeking world.
3. Patterns Get Exposed Like Old Wallpaper
Sometimes the only way to recognize your bad habits is by laying your full history out in the open. You begin to see that you always pick the same kind of partner, or that you always respond the same way in conflict. Therapy looks at your behavior and names it. Once it has a name, it can be handled before the cycle repeats again.
4. The Room Becomes A Mirror
This mirror is metaphorical, although some offices are a little generous with their reflective surfaces. A good therapist reflects your words back at you. Hearing them in someone else’s mouth feels uncanny, sometimes embarrassing, but it’s also quite clarifying.
Priscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦 on Unsplash
5. Language Becomes Medicine
Finding the exact word for something—be it grief, envy, or betrayal—organizes the chaos into the orderliness of language. Giving something a name takes the jumble of feelings and condenses it into something concrete. Words are a starting point for you to be able to handle those unwieldy emotions.
6. Ritual Works Even If You Don’t Believe In It
Every Thursday at 4 p.m. you show up, sit in the same chair, and sip the same lukewarm water from the paper cup. Repetition itself can be healing in its own way, anchoring you into a routine when so much of your life feels entirely out of your control.
7. It Gives Permission To Feel Selfish
While you’re in that room for that hour, it’s all about you. You can rant and rave about your drama, boredom, dreams, and all your petty annoyances. How many other places in life let someone be so self-absorbed without judgment?
8. Techniques Actually Stick Sometimes
The reality is there’s no magic bullet. Breathing exercises can help, as can journaling and CBT worksheets. Admittedly, these are small tools and aren’t particularly glamorous, but they wedge into the gears of bad habits and slow them down.
9. Stories Stop Twisting In Your Head
Recycling our worst moments can drive us into destructive habits. Once we’ve unpacked the breakup, the childhood slight, or the boss’s cruel remark, we can stop replaying those scenes like a scratched CD. Therapy doesn’t erase our worst moments, but it lowers the volume.
10. The Relationship Heals By Example
A good therapist maintains strong boundaries but is warm; they’re curious without being invasive; they’re consistent but not clingy. For many, it’s the healthiest relationship in their life. And by osmosis, it teaches how best to act.
As helpful as therapy can be, there are times when it just doesn’t work out. Here are ten reasons why that can happen.
1. The Therapist Is A Bad Fit
Sometimes you just instantly know that you aren’t compatible. Maybe it’s the way they frame their questions, or maybe it’s just an instinctive sense of distrust. Therapy with the wrong person can feel like quicksand—only with every word, you sink a little deeper.
2. Money Hangs Over Every Session
At $150 an hour, it’s sometimes difficult to keep your eyes from wandering to the clock. It’s easy to start measuring your emotional progress in dollar signs. When this happens, you may find yourself resenting your therapist when a session meanders.
3. Talking Isn’t Enough
The truth is there are problems that words don’t fix. Sometimes depression clings to us and our trauma is etched into our very body. At times, conversation can’t always trigger the epiphany that sets us free, no matter how eloquent our therapist is.
4. The Tools Feel Too Simple
“Have you tried meditating?” lands flat when you’re in existential despair. Filling out cognitive behavioral therapy worksheets can feel like kindergarten math while your life is burning down around you.
5. Therapists Are Human Too
When you’re vulnerable, little things can feel like major slights. Your therapist yawns or forgets an important detail, and suddenly you find yourself bottling up again. Sometimes they give bad advice that lingers in your mind long after, undermining the good advice they’ve previously offered.
6. Progress Can Be Glacial
It can be frustrating when, after weeks of talking, you’re still enmeshed in the same problems. When solutions are slow in coming, you start to wonder if it’s working or if you’re just feeding a meter.
7. Cultural Gaps Show
A therapist may not understand your particular family dynamics if they’re shaped by a culture, language, or history that they don’t share. They may nod politely, but their advice feels foreign, even irrelevant.
Antoni Shkraba Studio on Pexels
8. Insurance And Paperwork Kill Momentum
Having to fill out paperwork for insurance or getting limits on sessions per month can suffocate healing. Therapy can’t work if it’s too bogged down in bureaucracy.
9. You’re Not Ready
Sometimes you don’t actually want to change, at least not yet. You go through the motions, but secretly you’re clutching the old coping mechanisms tightly and refusing to let go. Therapy can’t pry them from your grip if you don’t want it to.
10. Expectations Crush It
Some people expect magical healing to take place in these sessions. One big revelation and suddenly a switch flips and you’re all better. Therapy isn’t that. When reality disappoints, people walk away, muttering about how pointless it all was.
KEEP ON READING
