×

Winning Arguments: 20 Debate Tips From Hostage Negotiators


Winning Arguments: 20 Debate Tips From Hostage Negotiators


Negotiating Like Your Life Depends On It

There’s a very famous book by an FBI hostage negotiator discussing the art of the argument. Taking this work in mind, there are many tips and tricks out there for winning debates and convincing people to come to your side. In fact, here are 20 tips that will make you quite persuasive and hard to deny.

Henri Mathieu-Saint-LaurentHenri Mathieu-Saint-Laurent on Pexels

1. Mirroring

Mirroring is an important tactic to be used during negotiations. This technique involves repeating the last few words the other person just said. This often makes the other person more comfortable and causes them to elaborate and share more information.

shallow focus of person holding mirrorVince Fleming on Unsplash

2. Win-Wins

Playing the ‘win-win’ game assumes that both sides are prepared to negotiate in good faith, which is rarely true in business. Playing it leaves you on the losing end or with both feeling dissatisfied if your counterpart is playing a ‘win-lose’ game. For high-stakes negotiation, it's good to remind yourself that no deal is much better than a bad deal.

four men sitting beside tableAshkan Forouzani on Unsplash

3. Labeling

Labeling is the act of naming the other side's emotions during a negotiation. If you can demonstrate that you understand your counterpart's feelings, then you gain trust and coax them to reveal more information about what they really need.

two men sitting on chair in front of tableKenan Buhic on Unsplash

Advertisement

4. Tactical Empathy

Tactical empathy involves showing interest in your counterpart's emotional state and viewpoint without indulging in gratuitous personal inquiries or sympathy. It's a shortcut to making a connection with your counterpart, building rapport, and negotiating in a time-efficient manner.

two handsToa Heftiba on Unsplash

5. The No’s

Setting up a “no” earlier in a negotiation allows your counterpart to feel safe and in control. As opposed to using fear and pressure to force a “yes” early on, giving your counterpart the freedom to say “no” relaxes the mind and makes open, honest conversation possible.

man riding bicycle beside wall with no textXavi Cabrera on Unsplash

6. Mislabeling

Mislabeling is a tactic in which you take the opposite approach of labeling by overstating or even fabricating hypothetical objections. By deliberately mislabeling your counterpart's feelings, you're forcing them to defend themselves, which in turn opens them up and gets them to reveal their true thoughts and priorities.

two women sitting at a table with laptopsResume Genius on Unsplash

7. Accusations

Literally tell the other side everything they hate about your deal before they have a chance to tell you. A preemptive strike that defuses pushback by resetting their emotional bar too low. It's a setup for loss aversion.

man pointing at cameraAdi Goldstein on Unsplash

8. Finding Leverage

Every negotiation has leverage. You just have to find it. One way is to look at what the other side will lose if the deal doesn't work and leverage their natural loss aversion. By making it a matter of loss, you can help shape the other side's decision.

two women sitting at a table looking at a cell phoneBrooke Cagle on Unsplash

9. Fairness

Fair is one of the most perilous words to drop in a negotiation. It fires up the amygdala and its associated emotional responses. Next time the fairness argument is raised, stop and apologize, and ask them to explain. Suddenly the burden is on them, and the issue stays on the table.

fernandozhiminaicelafernandozhiminaicela on Pixabay

Advertisement

10. Negotiating Styles

It's very important to know the negotiating style of your counterpart. Classify your negotiation partner into one of three categories. Are they an analyst, who considers all options? An assertive, who is concerned with speed and efficiency?

StockSnapStockSnap on Pixabay

11. Open-Ended Questions

Calibrated open-ended questions, particularly ones beginning with what or how, can help your counterpart open up to you. They can't be easily dismissed with terse replies like why or yes/no questions, so the discussion can continue.

a man standing next to a woman on a sidewalkThe Jopwell Collection on Unsplash

12. Common Ground

Look for common ground is a negotiation strategy where you establish a base for a collaborative, win-win negotiation and bring out the best in each other. By identifying areas of mutual interest, goals, values, experiences, and needs, you can build rapport, align priorities, foster trust, and create a sense of shared purpose.

woman sitting on swingBewakoof.com Official on Unsplash

13. Avoid Specifics

When asked about salary expectations, one of the worst things you can do is name a number first. If you absolutely have to, give a range or use a well-chosen odd number. Specific odd numbers like $4,671 seem more believable and researched than rounded numbers like $5,000.

woman in black long sleeve shirt holding white ceramic mugHelena Lopes on Unsplash

14. Understand First

The best way to get the outcome you desire is to try to understand your counterpart. The best way to do this is to ask your counterpart questions. When your counterpart feels that you are trying to understand them, it builds trust and rapport.

person sitting in a chair in front of a mancharlesdeluvio on Unsplash

15. Haggling Rules

The 65-85-95-100 rule is a negotiating technique in which you approach a haggle by starting at 65% of your budget and moving in small increments up to that. Each number gives the other side the impression that they have won a hard concession from you, when in fact you are merely negotiating towards your real target.

Customers interact with a cashier at a store.Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Advertisement

16. Small Talk

Negotiation doesn't require idle chit-chat to build trust. Listening is more important than talking to learn what's important and get a jump-start on trust. It saves time to skip the chase and respond to the other side's real interests.

two men talkingLinkedIn Sales Solutions on Unsplash

17. The Unknowns

Finding black swans is all about discovering the invisible unknowns that have the potential to upend a negotiation and swing it all in your favor. It's why getting your counterpart to speak is one of the best ways to hear about their true motivations and vulnerabilities. The best negotiators welcome surprises as an opportunity. When you're confused, it most likely means you’re missing vital information.

woman in white sweater holding black round framePriscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦 on Unsplash

18. Get Them Talking

Try to make the other side do most of the talking during a negotiation. The more they say, the more you learn about their needs, concerns, and vulnerabilities. Don't over-explain yourself because the more you talk, the more you may reveal weaknesses in your position.

two men sitting at a table talking to each otherJoel Danielson on Unsplash

19. Expect the Unexpected

Expect the expected. Most negotiations will present you with the same predictable turns and phases. For example, expect new information or negotiating ploys late in a negotiation, and have a plan to deal with them in advance.

woman in black crew neck shirt sitting on brown chairParabol | The Agile Meeting Tool on Unsplash

20. Listening

Listening is the most effective weapon in any argument. It is by listening carefully that you can detect your opponent's true fears, wants, and motivations and respond with compassion rather than hostility.

woman sitting on yellow armless chair near gray laptop computerMimi Thian on Unsplash


KEEP ON READING

 Alt
September 10, 2025
Subtle Tricks People Use To Twist The Truth. Manipulation rarely looks like someone twirling a mustache and chuckling to themselves.…
 Alt
September 9, 2025
Taming Your Inner Critic. You’ve probably heard it before: you’re your own worst critic. And sometimes, it feels like you…
 Alt
What's Going On Inside Your Head?. The brain is an incredibly complex organ that scientists have only just begun to…
 Alt
September 9, 2025
Negotiating Like Your Life Depends On It. There’s a very famous book by an FBI hostage negotiator discussing the art…
 Alt
September 8, 2025
The Lines You Roll Your Eyes At. Travel quotes are everywhere. You can find them splashed across airport gift shop…
 Alt
September 8, 2025
Everybody Stay Calm. Mass hysteria occurs when a group of people are afflicted with the same symptoms or fears but…